The Strategic Danger of Taking the Stand
This is the fourth and final instalment in our October series breaking down the procedural realities of British Columbia traffic court.
In a BC traffic trial, the defence case begins only after the prosecution closes its case. At this stage, the self-represented driver faces what may be the single most important strategic decision of the entire proceeding: whether to testify.
Under Canadian law, a defendant never has to take the stand. The burden of proof rests entirely on the government. If the police officer fails to prove even an essential element of the offence beyond a reasonable doubt, the ticket must be dismissed, regardless of whether you say a single word in defence.
Still, almost every self-represented driver immediately steps into the witness box.
They assume that if they do not personally swear an oath and explain their actions, the court will find them guilty by default. This instinct often turns a winnable case into an outright conviction.
It may be the right thing to do to take the witness stand. Even then we see self-represented individuals take the witness stand and fail to testify about essential elements of the case that could lead to success at trial. Simply put, they think they need to tell their story but they fail to cover the parts that are important for the legal determination.
And of course, when you take the witness stand, you surrender your right to silence. The moment you testify, the police officer or Crown counsel earns the legal right to cross-examine you under oath.
Police officers conduct cross-examinations constantly.
They know how to ask sharp, leading questions designed to pin you down, extract admissions, and expose inconsistencies in your recollection.
Frequently, drivers end up proving the government’s case for them. An officer might have forgotten to lead evidence on an essential element, such as the exact municipality, the exact direction of travel, or whether the speed-monitoring device was properly tested. But when the driver takes the stand to explain that they were running late, the cross-examiner asks, “And you were operating your vehicle westbound on that stretch of road at approximately 8:45 AM, correct?” The driver answers yes, and the missing element is instantly established.
Furthermore, if you bring a witness to testify, you may not lead them. Asking, “You saw that the signal was green, right?” will often draw an immediate objection. You must know how to elicit relevant facts using proper, open-ended questions. Now it is true that an open-ended question may be permissible. But even then, the weight given to an answer to an open-ended question is unlikely to raise a reasonable doubt.
Challenging a violation ticket is a technical trial, not an informal hearing.
Points, heavy fines, and RoadSafetyBC driving prohibitions are on the line.
More than 30 years ago, we stepped into traffic court to protect drivers because we recognized that the consequences of traffic tickets are so significant, the rules are complex, and lawyers were necessary to help people succeed when fighting a ticket.
We know the rules of evidence, we know the procedure, and we know how to defend your driving record. We are the original BC Driving Lawyers. If you are facing a violation ticket, call the original BC Driving Lawyers at 604-608-1200. We can help.