Skip to main content

Beating an Excessive Speeding Ticket Does Not Erase Your Impound Fees

Drivers stopped for travelling 41 km/h or more over the speed limit in British Columbia face two immediate consequences: a traffic violation ticket under section 148 of the Motor Vehicle Act and the mandatory roadside seizure of their vehicle.

Many drivers assume that disputing the ticket in traffic court solves both problems. They expect that if the court dismisses the ticket, the government or the police will reimburse the towing and impound storage bills.

That assumption is incorrect. Even if you dispute the ticket and win a complete dismissal in court, you remain on the hook for the towing charges and daily storage fees.

The Split Between Court and Administrative Law

The reason a court win does not wipe out your towing bill comes down to how the law divides responsibility between provincial traffic court and the administrative impoundment scheme.

When you dispute an excessive speeding ticket, your trial takes place in traffic court under the BC Offence Act. The prosecution bears the burden of establishing every element of the allegation beyond a reasonable doubt. If the justice finds a reasonable doubt on any essential element, the ticket is dismissed.

Vehicle impoundment operates on an entirely separate legal track. Section 251(1) of the Motor Vehicle Act confers direct statutory power on police officers to seize and impound a vehicle whenever they form reasonable grounds to believe an excessive speeding offence took place.

The traffic court justice has no jurisdiction over the administrative impoundment and cannot order RoadSafetyBC or the private tow lot to release funds. Because the roadside seizure was governed by whether the officer held reasonable grounds at the scene, a subsequent acquittal under the criminal standard of proof does not invalidate the original impoundment order.

The Two-Year Lookback: Previous Impoundment, Not Conviction

Under section 253 of the Motor Vehicle Act, the duration of an excessive speeding impound escalates based on your recent driving record:

  • First incident: The vehicle is impounded for a mandatory 7 days.
  • Second incident within two years: The impoundment period escalates to 30 days. A third occurrence within that same two-year window triggers a 60-day impound.

The critical detail most drivers miss is that this escalation does not require a prior conviction in traffic court.

Section 253 does not ask whether you were found guilty of excessive speeding after a trial. It looks strictly at whether you were subjected to a previous administrative impoundment under section 251 within the preceding two years.

Even if you successfully challenged your first excessive speeding ticket in court, the fact that your vehicle was impounded for 7 days remains an administrative event in RoadSafetyBC’s records. If an officer stops you again for excessive speeding within that two-year window, that earlier roadside seizure alone is enough to trigger a 30-day impound.

In British Columbia driving law, relying on an unproven prior administrative seizure to escalate a subsequent administrative penalty is uncommon. With an Immediate Roadside Prohibition (IRP), for example, an earlier driving ban does not automatically serve as the sole trigger for later, escalated administrative driving bans in the same manner. While using a prior, untried roadside event to justify harsher administrative consequences might raise constitutional questions in other legal contexts, the statutory design of the vehicle impoundment regime operates on this basis.

Daily storage rates at private impound lots add up quickly, and a 30-day impound routinely results in tow and storage bills well above $1,000 before the vehicle can be retrieved.

Challenging a 30-Day Impound: The Available Defences

If you receive a standard 7-day impound for excessive speeding, the legislation provides no right of administrative review. You must wait out the full seven days and pay the tow yard directly to regain possession.

Reviews through RoadSafetyBC are only available for impoundments of 30 days or longer.

If your vehicle faces a 30-day seizure, you have 15 calendar days from the date of the impoundment notice to file an application for review with the Superintendent of Motor Vehicles.

The primary grounds to contest a 30-day impound include:

  1. Incorrect impoundment period (no qualifying prior impound): This is often the most viable legal challenge. Section 253 permits a 30-day impound only if you were subject to a previous qualifying impound within the preceding two years. If the police ran your record incorrectly, misidentified you roadside, relied on an impound that falls outside the two-year window, or mistakenly attributed another driver’s impound history to you, the 30-day duration is legally invalid.
  2. Unauthorized use: The vehicle was taken without the owner’s knowledge or consent.
  3. Owner diligence: The vehicle was loaned to someone, and the owner exercised reasonable care and diligence to ensure the vehicle would not be used in an unsafe manner.
  4. Economic hardship (business vehicles only): The vehicle is essential to a business operation, and the seizure threatens the enterprise with substantial financial harm. Personal financial strain on an individual driver does not meet this threshold.
  5. Compassionate grounds: Strictly defined circumstances where an eligible individual living with the owner requires the vehicle for education, employment, or critical medical treatment, and no alternative transportation exists.

Establishing economic hardship or compassionate grounds is notoriously difficult. Disputing whether the officer properly established a qualifying previous impound on your record is far more concrete and defensible.

Talk to BC Driving Lawyers

An excessive speeding allegation carries immediate costs, three penalty points, high-risk insurance premiums, and the possibility of a licence suspension issued by RoadSafetyBC. Disputing the ticket in court remains essential to protecting your driving record and licence status, even though the impound fees remain distinct.

If you were ticketed for excessive speeding or had your vehicle impounded for 30 days in British Columbia, contact the team at BC Driving Lawyers right away to discuss your legal options.